A landmark result at the Santiago Bernabéu was achieved, yet the performance left the manager with more questions than answers. Manchester City secured a memorable 2-1 Champions League victory over Real Madrid, but the nature of the win highlighted a persistent issue that has shadowed the team this season: a troubling lack of control.
The opening half-hour in Madrid was a harrowing experience for the visitors. A defensive error, a contentious penalty call, and relentless pressure culminated in an early deficit. While the character to fight back—through goals from Nico O’Reilly and Erling Haaland—was commendable, the pattern of the match was unsettling. The final 15 minutes mirrored the frantic start, with City clinging on as Madrid struck the woodwork in search of an equaliser.
For a manager whose philosophy is built on dominance and game management, these extended periods of chaos are a clear concern. This season has seen several alarming examples: surrendering a two-goal lead to narrowly beat Leeds, a 5-1 advantage almost evaporating against Fulham, and nervous moments even in a comfortable win over Sunderland. The team’s identity has shifted; the methodical, suffocating possession that once defined them has given way to a more direct approach, heavily reliant on the prowess of Erling Haaland.
This tactical evolution makes them explosive but also vulnerable, especially when they lose the ball. Against elite opponents like Madrid, with attackers capable of devastating transitions, any lapse can be punished. The head coach acknowledged the problem post-match, stating the team was “too late” in defensive recovery and emphasised the need to “control it a little bit more.”
The positive takeaway was the fearless contribution of the team’s younger talents. O’Reilly, in particular, showcased the bravery and technical ambition the manager demands, a welcome contrast to what was perceived as timidity in a recent defeat. These performances are part of a necessary growth process for a squad in transition.
Ultimately, the victory in Madrid proves this team can beat anyone on their day. The spirit is undeniable. However, the path to the biggest trophies is typically paved with consistency and defensive solidity. The current propensity for rollercoaster encounters introduces a level of jeopardy not associated with this club in recent years. While it may make for compelling viewing, the pressing question remains: can a team that so often loses its grip on matches still maintain a grip on silverware? The manager knows improvements are essential.